“There isn’t a ‘best school’, just a ‘best school for your child”
Sir Anthony Seldon.
Is an independent school right for your child? That was the question posed by Sir Anthony Seldon, one of Britain’s leading contemporary educationalists, in his keynote at The School Show in London last month. He offered the pros and cons of an independent education, but repeatedly urged the parents in the audience to “Choose the school for your child, not yourself.”
The decision to invest in an independent education is substantial, both financially and emotionally. As echoed in the Independent School Parent magazine, it is about doing what’s right for your child, acknowledging their unique abilities and needs. Some children will thrive in a competitive environment, while others will flourish in a more nurturing or creative setting. Thankfully, the UK boasts a wide range of established independent schools, each with its own excellent reputation and bespoke offering.
So, what are the tangible benefits that draw families to an independent education?
1. Smaller Class Sizes
This is often cited as a primary benefit, and for good reason. The Independent Schools Council (ISC) census reveals a stark contrast: an average pupil-teacher ratio of 8.8:1 in independent schools compared to 18.0:1 in state schools. Many independent classes have just 12 to 15 pupils. This allows staff the time and resources to approach each child as an individual, and to personalise support fr them, eliciting the greatest development within each child.
2. A Purposeful Atmosphere and Strong Discipline:
Independent schools often cultivate an environment of strong discipline and a purposeful atmosphere. This is not about rigid rules, but about fostering a culture of respect, accountability, and dedication to learning. Clear expectations and a supportive framework help students to focus, thrive, and develop self-discipline, essential for academic success and personal growth.
3. A More Extensive Range of Extracurricular Activities & Trips
One of the most striking differentiators is the sheer breadth of extracurricular activities and trips offered. From extensive sports programs and competitive debating to diverse clubs, drama productions, music ensembles, and expeditions, independent schools provide unparalleled opportunities for students to explore their passions, develop new skills, and build character.
4. Pastoral Care is More Significant
The emphasis on pastoral care in independent schools is often significantly more robust. Dedicated tutors, Heads of House, and counsellors create a strong support network, focusing on students’ emotional, social, and physical well-being. This comprehensive approach helps students navigate challenges, build confidence, and develop a strong moral compass. As Andrew McGarva, Rector at Morrison’s Academy in Crieff, highlights, “Having pupils from age two up to 18 allows us to shape the whole school experience. It really does mean that we have the privilege of developing the whole child.”
5. Academic Focus
While universal development is key, academic excellence remains a core pillar. Independent schools offer superior academic focus and assistance, often providing bespoke curriculums and targeted support. Whether it is extra help for those who need it or challenging enrichment for the gifted, the goal is to unlock each child’s full academic potential. The results speak for themselves, with independent school pupils consistently achieving strong academic outcomes.
6. Alumni Networks Creating Lifelong Connections
The alumni networks of independent schools are often incredibly strong and supportive. These networks provide invaluable connections, mentorship opportunities, and a sense of lifelong belonging. Graduates benefit from a robust professional and personal network, opening doors and offering guidance long after they have left the school gates.
7. Community, Volunteering, Culture
The community and culture within independent schools are also a significant benefit. Voluntary work, from visiting local care homes to helping at the local food bank, instils a sense of civic duty and promotes compassion.
Choosing a school for your child or children is a difficult decision, whether you go for state or independent is just one part of that equation, and something that you need to consider carefully. Involving your child in the decision can make a big impact on how well they accept the choice and how quickly they settle, so please do consider making them a part of the process.
